TravelTalkOnline Forums Travel and Vacation Forums St. Maarten - St. Martin The Best?

Old Cranky Todd’s rant of the day ! I hope you laugh along, a bit.

What is it with people that post that “this is the best…”blank”..on island”. Not stating this is the “best I have had”, but simply this “blank” is the best on island!

I will start with a common one, a hamburger. I will state that life could be spent searching for the best hamburger and it would not be a life wasted. Besides it being a matter of opinion, how many have you tried on island? I figured that I have had burgers from around 35 different places on island, based on my estimate is I have tried 15% of the places that serve a burger on island. I don’t think I could tell you my favorite of the 35, let alone estimate the other two hundred places that serve burgers on island. I think it would be insulting for me with my limited experience to try to state which is best.

Car rental – seriously, I realize pimp’n ain’t easy but have you rented from all 40 or so companies? NO! I am not even sure of who I would say is the best out of the 10 or so companies I rented from. I would note, not a bad experience with any of them. Share your favorites and why, but relax on the pimp’n a bit, it is annoying.

If you belong to a FB site or other website that channels island businesses who are being suggested by their “experts” to sponsors that pay them ransom, leave the bs site because they are not experts. They are paid to direct you to those sponsors. Don’t be a lemming, find sites that give you unbiased ideas based on their experiences not who is paying them for pimp’n services. Many of you know who I am referring to.

I have enjoyed most of my over 20 years now on TTOL, rant over, for now. Merry Christmas!
T

Hey Todd, did MJ tell you that you were getting coal in your stocking this year???

Happy holidays!!

I very much agree with your accounts, especially about the facebook sites, one in particular. You are being steered towards a business they have some affiliation with, design their website or get something in return for their "expert" opinion. It is akin to shopping the cruise lines "recommended" stores. Big $$ spent on advertising and big % of $$ back to the cruise line when a purchase is made.

One the "best" burger thing, I have had a good one and one that was not so good at the same place a year or two apart.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays.

Merry Christmas. I thought your rant was going to morf into the "Best of St Maarten" poll the Herald is coming out with again.

I can't tell you how much I love this post 😍

Best post I have read in a long, long time!!!!!
Happy Holidays!

I so agree with you, Todd. It isn't just the Facebook sites; it's here as well. How can anyone possibly state something is "the best" unless ALL alternatives have been tried? They can't, and it's a ridiculous statement. Thanks for posting.

I agree withGaKaye----love this post. And with LB12SXM it's the BEST post, and boy have I read quite a few; some negivave, some pushing a place too much without thought to how many people have the same needs here.. but it's better than a bunch of negativity.

You made my day today and I just might stuff you in one of my stockings to hang over the fireplace. Oh wait---I'm not sure what's my BEST one.

They can only state it's the "best" if they add "in my own opinion" then it's more qualified to their criteria. But to act as a know it all and declare with authority it's the "best" is BS.

Very interesting topic/rant I also agree your best and my best could be polar opposites.
Now Hamburgers or cheeseburgers from Slovenia to Taiwan and In between I have sent a many to the gallows. The best I have ever had came from my grill. Now on a side note during covid my job had me in Taiwan and after a 2 week quarantine in a Taiwan hotel eating only traditional Taiwan food being the only American there in that hotel. Once released I stopped at a McDonald's and that big Mac was GREAT so good I ate 2.
So best also depends for me on where I am and what are my options and how hungry I'm I 😋

And I think this is the BEST POST! Merry Christmas!!🎄😎🎄

Perfectly said and so spot on. Thank you, Todd, I think we have a new ‘Voice of Reason’ in the making.

Merry Christmas!

Um.....

Am I able to say that TravelTalk Online is the BEST site for informed advice regarding travel, especially to St Martin?

Only if it is best for you.😉🤣

Great post! I do appreciate people sharing when they've had a good meal or experience, but your “best” one might not rate based on what I'm looking for. My daughter did try to find the best molten chocolate dessert one year. We stayed in Grand Case for a week and ate at a six of the great restaurants on the main street and she had the chocolate dessert at every one that offered it! Of course I don't remember who she ranked best anymore.

STmartinfan
You had me at chocolate Moulton cake

And a good chance they are all made at the same bakery.

Probably true that.

No, molten chocolate desserts are not made at a bakery. The batter has to be placed in the oven for a short time just before serving. They were all good, but different in texture, how dark the chocolate was, size of serving and other characteristics.

i can't agree more with this post. and the winner is...........

I am glad the post was well received by most, at least those who responded.

Carol - MJ thought about it but coal is a bad investment right now, price keeps dropping.
Pat - The voice of reason is a one person title that remains yours, but I take that as a big compliment. Others probably laughed hard at that thought of me taking on that kind of role!

Back on island in 8 days for a short one week trip.

All the "best" to all of you!

Todd--Sorry, why should you be grumpy, when you just got home, and going back in 8 days????

Anyway, happy holidays, everyone!!!

I always love me some Todd!! Right on Todd with everything you said and many feel that way but won't say it!!

i don’t agree with too much stuff posted on this site, but i agree with this thread…i’ve even commented in the past that some threads are just thinly veiled ads for some businesses…comment was quickly deleted

and i’m pretty sure i’ve read comments like “best glass of water i’ve ever had”, or “best piece of dry toast ever!”…i get it that many here are obsessed with SXM, but such over exaggerations are silly and i don’t think actually have the impact that is intended

and what’s the point of responses like if someone asks, “where’s the best restaurant for “x”, and someone responds, “i don’t know, i don’t like eating “x” ?….or someone asks “i often visit “y”, but would like to try some alternatives “, and someone responds “i only go to “y”, nowhere else”. ?

In 24 hours I won't be grumpy! I have been summoned by the Queen, a Princess and a Prince to return. I will faithfully abide, see you all soon!

This trip may have to last a while, but will enjoy being there and being seen!

Cheers!

I know who you’re refering to, I think……….

Todd, Thanks for the most common sense post I have read on any forum in a long time!

Hahahaha. See you soon!

If Dominos wins again on The Daily Herald poll I think it must be the best pizza, would be like a 20 time winner. 😅