Aqua Bistro in Coral Bay, St. John has all you can eat Anegada lobster on Monday nights for $58. Friends who live on St. John ate there last night and had great things to say. The photos showed mass lobster carnage.
Aqua Bistro is a very good restaurant with fair/poor dinghy access next to Dolphin Market. No dinghy dock, but there is a spot to lock your dinghy on the shore. It requires you to wade in knee high water. You can also do a flat 2/3 mile walk from the dinghy dock at Skinny Legs.
Cheers, RickG