We all have our favorites. As Pat stated Beachside Villas is great but having been to Jost Van Dyke & St John's (Maho Camps, Concordia) our "breakfast, beach, walk, lunch, nap, beach again," then dinner in a great French restaurant is a stay at Grand Case Beach Club in Grand Case, a once French fishing village, now with a multitude of small intimate restaurants all with great food.
Almost every year we go to Ste Martin but alternate with places in built up, resort areas and renting a car to drive around island for different eateries, with a do nothing but relax, eat, beach , sleep no car rental stay at GCBC.