Update--I called again this evening and was able to get them to honor the price which shows up on the website. They had to issue me a credit and then apply it toward the booking, in order to do so, but at least they honored the price on their website. I spent a lot of time over $5, but the thing just p*ssed me off, as Jet Blue has already screwed me over a couple of times in the past..
By the way, there is a KNOWN PROBLEM with the website, as far as Jet Blue is concerned, according to the (much more helpful) person I talked to this evening. If you try to book a one way ticket from SXM (or anywhere else outside the country, I presume) you will NOT be able to use a credit card that has a US address. The system will ALWAYS decline your credit card.
.
