IMHO..I would not cut out Anegada and maybe drop Peter. While in Trellis check out Marina Cay's restaurant and bar. We sailed there yesterday and had a truly great lunch..a far cry from the old days when you went for the charm of the island but never for the cuisine! I also think Cane Garden Bay on a non cruise ship day ( they are Wed and Thurs at least at the moment).Its a beautiful beach..stroll west and stop at Indigo House...