Be careful. I started by giving up my charters for Anegada land stays and now I live in Cane Garden Bay. You are headed down a dangerous path...
Ha ha! We live on a small lake and own a larger boat for the big lake (Lake Michigan) . . . it would be hard to give this up completely! And we'll still be sailing in the BVI's - just finding a crew who can go as often as we'd like is hard ;-)
Consider yourself warned. My larger boat on Lake Erie is going into storage this week. Your story is very similar...