No, that is not correct. I would expect to pay about $75 roundtrip for the two of you, including tip, DEPENDING on whether you are really late leaving Simpson Bay. If you're after midnight leaving to go home, I would guesstimate about $10 more.
Suggest you contact TTOL sponsor Wilfred Brooks on the sponsors list. He is a really good guy, careful driver, and will pick you up at your condo and take you and pick you up again, at a prearranged time. Or if you have a phone, you could call him when you're ready. If it's before 11 or so, you could probably just get a cab wherever you are without pre-arranging it.
.
