Thanks for the suggestions. I, too, was confused about what was or wasn't public, although ultimately if it's just a matter of it being "tacky" or "frowned upon", I'm not going to do it anyway. I couldn't tell from my previous reading on the area, just how many options for rental there were...it sounds like the Anse Marcel Beach Club is a lovely place and worth the splurge, so I think we will check it out.