Todd, we definitely met you and MJ at the first party you hosted at Karakter. Not sure what year it was, and we seem to have this discussion every year on the island, lol. Maybe one day we'll figure it out
Edited to add that I found, in an old trip report of mine, mention of you and MJ hosting a party at Karakter in 2009.
Edited again! I found an old photo on Facebook, we met on November 28, 2008!! Finally the mystery is solved!
Apologies to other TTOLers who couldn't care less.