just FYI, in Anguilla you drive on the left...not a big deal, since it's a very flat island, with not a lot of traffic...very laid back

consider Andy's Car Rental, which is just outside the ferry terminal....his website doesn't seem to be working, but i believe he's still in business...just Google Andy's Car Rental Anguilla, and you should be able to find contact info...or just ask for him when you get off the ferry, most everyone will know where to find him

another FYI, when you rent a car, you will also have to pay for a driving "permit"...i think it was $15-20...so total price for a car, including permit, should be ~$50/day

Andy's Car Rental