Signman - Boomerang was the other boat I was looking at! Do you know what it has for extras? Tennessee Waltz has a water and ice maker which is nice and the dinghy is 12 feet which seems big than the tiny things we had last year. BVI also gave us a discount if we book early, I'll have to see if TMM does that.
Winterstale - do you know what area of FL you are thinking of? West coast and east coast can be so different. I ended up here because this is where my husband grew up.