I agree, OP needs to state what type of accomodation you are getting at the various places. At Simpson Bay Resort Villas, the studios are ludicrously small, with only a dorm sized fridge and a tiny balcony. However, the 1 BR units are very nice. For Atrium and Simpson Bay Resort, are you getting ocean view?? And what type of unit? For Atrium, if it's not ocean view, you get a view of the back of the Market Garden, complete with their huge a/c units, which are very noisy. Club O is hard to figure in with the others because of the nude factor, as far as how important that is to you. For roughly the same money, I would take Horny Toad every day of the week, over Turquoise Shell, as TS is not on the beach. The only thing TS has is a pool, but I'd rather have the spectacular beach that HT has. At Mary's Boon, are you looking at an oceanfront room? Because if not, then I would eliminate that straight off, as being more expensive than the other options. Have you stayed at any of these places before? When all is said and done, I personally would do Beachside, as I personally think it's the best place on earth, for ME. Your mileage may vary.
.
