I second what Roger (SeeDiver) said. C&F was recommended to us by the staff at BVIYC. It is within walking distance. We loved that it had a local vibe to it. It accommodated our group of ten easily. Pretty slow service but we were all on vacation and it didn't bother us at all as we were there to relax and have a good time. Very nice and friendly staff as well.
They had a special pasta dish that was AWESOME!
I haven't been there since 2014 but we plan to go back in 2016 again as well.
.
