Interesting indeed! Well I haven’t been referred to as “bonkers” in awhile. That is kind of funny. Our first visit to Saint Martin was in 1990. Safe to say we have visited all the beaches on the Island over the years.
Sorry, my post was sort if in jest.
I just think that it is very hard for an all-inclusive hotel in Anse Marcel to really do well. Most people visit this wonderful island for the great variety and excellent dining options as well as the beaches.
I think you said you used points so it's sort of free. I just cannot imagine a dinner at Secrets would be similar to a nice dinner in Grand Case, but I could be totally wrong.
As long as your enjoying your vacation it doesn't matter what I think!