Pretty tough to give Secrets a bad review noting they are not even open yet post remodel. It is a great beach, and while I am sure the AI food options will not match much of the island it still probably will be decent, and included. You can always go to other places on island as well. It is great that Secrets is now part of Hyatt, my favorite of the hotel points programs. Using Hyatt points at their all inclusive resorts is usually a pretty good deal as well.
.
