We were at La Villa last night, Food was good and the service was excellent, there was not an empty seat in the house by 6:30. There is a restaurant that opened where Pascual was, can't recall the name, We ate there a few years ago, and did not think it was as good, though a small sample size. Quay 58 is newish - https://www.st-martin.org/restaurant/quai-58/ we had appetizers there last year and it was quite good. Not sure how long since you have last been back, but Calmos is now reopened.