Look into Hertz sxm. The island one not the national chain as the aren't the same. Deal directly with them on island.
Are you saying wait until I get to the island to deal with them? Or are you saying deal directly with the link on the island?
I think Kenny might be who I deal with though. I have not been to the island for over 7 years now, summer of 2017. I rented from Hertz in 2017, but Kenny in 2016. I'm sure Kenny doesn't remember, but he was great to rent from as was Hertz. I don't care what kind of car I drive as long as it works. Kenny has offered the best deal to me since I have been asking for quotes this time. I don't know for sure if he will try to force me to get liability insurance or not though. I don't know for sure what I'm doing as far as car rental yet though.
.
