Having not eaten at PP for several years (never a bad experience, just tried other places), I went this past trip and it was good and they were busy. 5 first-timers were having dinner there and I had arranged to meet them for drinks as I knew one of them. 4 of the 5 really enjoyed their meals and the one who was disappointed did not understand what their version of lobster thermidor was. I know it is not gourmet but as busy as they were, they must still be pretty good and many locals frequent the place as well.