I try to avoid giving expectations, everyone's experience is different and even a place like the Baths can be a let down depending on the day. I just have a mental list of places to go and when we get there (if we even get there) we just sort of roll with it. My newbie crew LOVED Anegada (some people hate it so I didn't "build it up" before) . The Baths was not a great experience when its crowded. We enjoyed Soggy and Foxy's for a bit but explored other stops on JVD, like Ali Babas. Willy T was a hit but it was a popping night and we had young folks, They LOVED the Blunder Bay restaurant with the pool but thought BEYC was meh. Cane Garden Bay was a hit for all but that's because over the years we have come to know many of the folks there which makes it "homey" for us and they got that vibe as well. They loved Smugglers and the island adventure to get there. Anyway point is I never said to them these things are "must do's" that's a sure fire way to jinx it!!
.
