AI or not?
As already noted, SXM is really not a great AI destination but if it’s worth doing from a financial standpoint, why not?! There’s no rule that says you MUST take every meal and/or drink there. If it’s your first trip to the island or you’re not at all adventurous, this option can certainly lower your stress levels.
But honestly, SXM is known as the “Gourmet Capital of the Caribbean’ for a reason. From the lowliest beach bbq shack to the best restaurants in the island, there is something to be truly enjoyed for every taste bud and pocketbook and it would be a shame to miss out on completely missing the island dining.
The approach we’ve taken a few times on first time vacations to new to us destinations is to try the AI option for breakfasts, lunches if on site, and occasional drinks, but once we figure out the lay of the land, we venture out and try some of the popular restaurants other visitors recommend.
Good luck with your trip whatever you finally do. We will celebrate our 50th year of annual SXM vacations next year and we’ve yet to be disappointed and over all those trips and years we have only experienced two less than excellent meals.