This is the go to list for the most up to date seasonal closings -

http://www.stjohnspice.com/stjohnrestaurants.htm

Our favorites in no particular order -

Morgan's Mango
Lime Inn
Ocean Grill (lunch more than dinner)
Rhumblines

In February, we had good enough meals at the High Tide and Banana Deck.

Sam and Jack's Deli in the Marketplace complex has very good take out.