HMmmm, seemed like ^^^^ boats had lots of issues.
May I recommend TMM Charters, who consistently has great reviews here. (Full disclosure, my Lagoon 42, Sea Tiger, is in TMM Charters. Am I prejudiced? Or is it the reason I chose TMM Charters?)
To be fair, in my experience TMM Charters is consistently one of if not the best charter companies in the BVI. Their service is great, charter debriefings are throughout and boats are always impeccably maintained. You usually pay a little more than going with Sunsail, Moorings, or DYC. But if you want a reliable boat in great shape, it is worth it.
.
