Easy choice if it was me. Royal Islander LaPlage...hands down. Close to a ton of restaurant choices, Casino Royale right across the street....market across the street.....secured parking....and the place has never looked better. Also....sand gravity does kick in.....and nice beach right there at the resort...and it is NOT downhill walking like it is at both Simpson Bay area and La Vista. We have been going to LaPlage for over thirty years...and LOVE it. Also was very impressed on how they fixed up since Irma.