One advantage to chartering in the BVIs is the option of provisioning on line. I have not read here about any such option in the USVI. I can’t imagine what a pain it would be to rent a car then spend hours trying to provision for one or two weeks of the charter.
A car isn’t necessary, a supermarket is right up the road from CYOA if anything you might want to take a taxi back to the boat for ten dollars.
.
