if you are looking to lay low after charter, I would visit Cane Garden Bay while on charter and then stay in Apple Bay at the end (it is not a place you would visit by boat) that way you get the best of both worlds....rent a car or cab it and pop over to Soper's (shopping and Scaramouche for dinner) , visit Smugglers, Bananakeet for dinner one night. However, if you are more into the nightlife and have no plan or desire to rent a car CGB would be better. You can't go wrong either way!!!