There is a Riteway in Fat Hogs Bay. It is not as good as the one in Pasea (outskirts of Roadtown) but pretty good. We have provisioned from there quite happily for the past five years. Nowadays you can get most things in BVI, not as good as UK stores but acceptable. (Dont know what is acceptable in US, but presumably much the same). You just have to base what you are going to eat around what you can buy. Fun, if occasionally challenging. Things have improved considerably over the past ten years or so in BVI. An open mind when shopping is the most important item on your list. Get your alcohol in advance, delivered from Carribean Cellars.